See Product
Hi Fran, we are sorry to hear you were not satisfied with the product you ordered. Our customer service team will be reaching out to see how we can make this right, possibly taking advantage of our "Love It, or Return It" policy.
Reviews for Pillow Case
What Customers Are Saying AI Generated Summary
- Soft Fabric: Many reviewers describe the pillowcase as very soft and comfortable, and kids love sleeping on it.
- Personal Gift: Customers love adding names, photos, and favorite themes for grandkids, anniversaries, and gag gifts.
- Thin & White Back: Some found the fabric thinner than expected and noted the back is plain white rather than printed.
- Not Cotton: A few expected cotton and noted the fabric is a soft, stretchy polyester.
Customer Reviews (Newest Reviews First)
If I could give a 0 rating I would. The fabric is very thin. I doubt it will hold up to frequent use and many washings even on gentle wash and air dry. Won't buy from this company again if this is an indication of their other products.
Reviewer: Fran F | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 22, 2026
Product: Photo Pillow Case
Personalized pillowcases make wonderful gifts for many occasions! Birthday, wedding, Christmas, house-warming; even sleepover parties or for weekend guests!
One can't go wrong ordering personalized gifts through customizeit. I received wonderful feedback about the personalized pillowcase gifts. And I love mine too!
I remember having to personalize gifts through Lillian Vernon back in the day. However, with numerous styles to choose from, this is the best company to order personalized gifts from. Why not design a genealogical family tree throw, for the next gift I would like to order?
Reviewer: Brenda-Louise Pretlor | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 02, 2026
Product: Watercolor Mandala Pillow Case (Personalized)
I made a design for my granddaughter as I just want finding what I wanted. It came out beautifully! She's going to be so excited!
Reviewer: Donalee Dragna | Verified Customer
Date: May 30, 2026
Product: Pillow Case (Upload Your Own)
I highly recommend this product. It turned out exactly as I had hoped. And the cost was reasonable. I will use this site again, for sure!
Reviewer: Mary Gioco | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 17, 2025
Product: Cow Print Pillow Case (Personalized)
These are perfect! Exactly what I wanted! Thank you!
Reviewer: Dianne Opilla | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 01, 2022
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Had a pillow case made for my girlfriend. I had a little trouble knowing what to do with the image and design, but a sales coordinator helped me through it. Picture and product quality was excellent and it arrived right on time.
Reviewer: ADAM | Verified Customer
Date: Nov 16, 2022
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
The material on this pillowcase was very thin even though it is soft. The graphic is nice but it was very washed out looking and the color is only on the front and the back of the pillow is white, very disappointing for the amount of money I paid.
Reviewer: Kim Carson | Verified Customer
Date: Aug 08, 2022
Product: Lotus Pose Pillow Case (Personalized)
Hello Kim, we are sorry to hear you were not completely satisfied with your purchase. We want all our customers to be happy with their products so our customer service team will be reaching out to see if you would be interested in our "Love It, or Return It" guarantee.
Great people to work with and great product as well. I'll order again.
Reviewer: Carolyn Hayes | Verified Customer
Date: Jun 30, 2022
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Loved it. Very long for any pillow . Waiting for a break on blanket ($180.+) and will get that and more. Lamp shades and curtains, switch covers all beautiful.
Reviewer: Augustine Mantia | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 06, 2022
Product: Irises (Van Gogh) Pillow Case
The pillow cases look great. Just what we ordered. They arrived in a timely manner. Thank You.
Reviewer: Matthew Murphy | Verified Customer
Date: Feb 04, 2022
Product: Pink Camo Pillow Case (Personalized)
These pillowcases turned out great! They exceeded my expectations. Thank you
Reviewer: Tara Zilinskas | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 23, 2021
Product: Graffiti Pillow Case (Personalized)
Quality service and fashion shipping.
Reviewer: Tina Owen | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 12, 2021
Product: Baseball Jersey Pillow Case (Personalized)
My grandson loves his pillow case. Very special and personal touch from his Meme. Thank you all for being high quality and special touches means so much to our family. Your company is wonderful to order from.
Reviewer: Lovetta G | Verified Customer
Date: Nov 01, 2021
Product: Sharks Pillow Case (Personalized)
Great quality!!
Reviewer: Melissa | Verified Customer
Date: Aug 05, 2021
Product: Swirls, Floral & Chevron Pillow Case (Personalized)
Ordered several items for our Retirement Lake home. Pretty colors, I think the guests will get a kick out of them. No issues, fast delivery & Recommend the Company! Seems to be well made but have not used them yet- we are inn the process of moving
Reviewer: Rebecca | Verified Customer
Date: Aug 02, 2021
Product: Lake House #2 Pillow Case (Personalized)
I ordered this item last minute as a birthday gift as was very anxious to have it sooner than promised. I spoke with customer service who promised she would follow up with the production department to see when it could be ready so that she could expedite shipment if it might be ready in time. She spoke with me literally every day after my order until she was able to tell me that it would be ready early and she could ship it overnight so it would arrive in time!! I was so impressed with the diligence of follow-up for this relatively small order. The cases themselves were perfectly done and looked and felt great. I will certainly order from the company again when I need a customized product!
Reviewer: Kathleen | Verified Customer
Date: May 23, 2021
Product: Moroccan Pillow Case (Personalized)
I love my pillow case, the only thing I don't care for is the material. It would be better if they were cotton blend so they didn't stretch so much.
Reviewer: Trina | Verified Customer
Date: May 18, 2021
Product: Skulls Pillow Case (Personalized)
Bought this for my 3 year old grandson. He loves fire trucks.
Reviewer: Kathryn | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 23, 2021
Product: Firefighter Character Pillow Case (Personalized)
This is beautiful just like the Sherpa blanket. I would want the option
of a colored or patterned back. The white shows up way to much
against our design.
Reviewer: Veronica | Verified Customer
Date: Mar 19, 2021
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
It wasnt what I expected, it ,
Reviewer: Bronte | Verified Customer
Date: Feb 20, 2021
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Hello Bronte, we will be reaching out to you to get some more information about how this product didn't meet your expectations and make sure that get a product you like.
Good quality
Reviewer: Sue | Verified Customer
Date: Oct 14, 2020
Product: Building Blocks Pillow Case (Personalized)
It is real soft and adds the finishing touches to his bed.
Reviewer: Loretta Martinez | Verified Customer
Date: Sep 15, 2020
Product: Pirate Scene Pillow Case (Personalized)
I took the photos from a cell phone message from a girlfriend of her kitties. I didn't think the quality would be good but I am pleasantly surprised how well the photo application on to the pillow case turned out. I know she will be thrilled.
Reviewer: A Irvin | Verified Customer
Date: Sep 05, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
I again was so pleased with the background and the lettering
Reviewer: david g becker | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 30, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
perfect for my grandaughter's new room!
Reviewer: Marilynn | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 20, 2020
Product: Ladybugs & Gingham Pillow Case (Personalized)
The fabric is soft and stretchy very comfortable
Reviewer: Smiley Best | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 07, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
They were perfect for our beds
Reviewer: Linda Williams | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 01, 2020
Product: Western Ranch Pillow Case (Personalized)
We love it!
Reviewer: Tanya Tamez | Verified Customer
Date: Jun 15, 2020
Product: Prince Pillow Case (Personalized)
Loved the pillow case. It is for my Granddaughter's birthday and I'm sure she is going to love it. Such a great idea. You did a very good job.
Reviewer: Linda Walsh | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 15, 2020
Product: Cheerleader Pillow Case (Personalized)
Had a pillowcase made to match the flag. It is very well made & have recommended this website/company to family & friends.
Reviewer: Cynthia Berger | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 14, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Cotton is the gift for the second anniversary. I scoured the Internet looking for a gift that would be suitable. Then I came across your Website and saw a series of cotton gifts. I hope it is obvious by now that the reader has figured out that we were married on St. Patrick's Day. Therefore, it only seemed fitting to have St. Patrick's Day themed gift for my wife. But what to have for the personalization: That was the question. I'll leave the meaning of the personalized statement to the mindset of the reader.
When my wife received this gift she busted out with laughter and almost hit the floor! She could not believe what she was holding and all the memories that it stirred up. It was truly a gift to behold! As far as the material of the gift, my wife stated that if was an extremely soft fabric that would create hours of comfort.
I will be keeping your company in mind for future gifts that are needed. But now I have to get to work on something whimsical for next year's anniversary.
Reviewer: Mark M | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 01, 2020
Product: St. Patrick's Day Pillow Case (Personalized)
I just love the pillowcase. It is for my granddaughter who turns 17 this month and she always says when doing something wrong, "at least I didn't", so she will truly enjoy receiving this
Reviewer: Maureen Johnson | Verified Customer
Date: Mar 15, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Exactly as ordered - perfect. I love the choices I had and how easy it was to navigate the site. So many choices - but I think this pillowcase is the best. thanks
Reviewer: nancy craven | Verified Customer
Date: Mar 15, 2020
Product: Polka Dots Pillow Case (Personalized)
The customize pillow case I ordered came out great. The fabric is soft and the text was perfect. I would order from them again.
Reviewer: Kimberly Daues | Verified Customer
Date: Feb 05, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Its awesome and the company as a whole is awesome
Reviewer: Jimmy Hubble | Verified Customer
Date: Feb 02, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
What a beautiful pillow case! My brother loved it!
Reviewer: Brad | Verified Customer
Date: Jan 01, 2020
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Arrived just in time and was exactly what I was hoping for!!
Reviewer: Kim. | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 25, 2019
Product: School Bus Pillow Case (Personalized)
So easy to do and I loved the way it turned out! It's also very soft material!
Reviewer: Shay Temm | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 23, 2019
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Nice, cute. Thought it would be cotton. But the fabric is ok. Not sure how it will be after a few washings.
Lots of choices in designs and templates.
Reviewer: Brenda | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 19, 2019
Product: Mermaid Pillow Case (Personalized)
The pillowcase is very soft and I think my grandson will love it. It is larger than I thought it would be for a standard size pillow.
Reviewer: Lorraine Cheros | Verified Customer
Date: Nov 13, 2019
Product: Sports Pillow Case (Personalized)
Absolutely beautiful! I couldn't be happier with the quality and design of the pillowcase. My Christmas presents are truly unique.
Reviewer: Deb | Verified Customer
Date: Oct 23, 2019
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
I love this!
Reviewer: Crystal Myers | Verified Customer
Date: Oct 11, 2019
Product: Polka Dot Butterfly Pillow Case (Personalized)
I am so happy with the product, it's exactly I wanted. The customer service support I received was phenomenal!
Reviewer: Angie | Verified Customer
Date: Aug 14, 2019
Product: Mother's Day Pillow Case
My grandson is carrying this item when he is tired. The pillow case comes handy. Thank you for such a wonderful top quality item!
Reviewer: Nancy Owens | Verified Customer
Date: Aug 11, 2019
Product: Firetrucks Pillow Case (Personalized)
My grandaughter is ecstatic with her personalized, sloth pillowcase. She wants to hang it up on the wall! Haven't laundered it yet but hopefully the softness will keep.
Who knew that a sloth would become a popular icon? We are very happy with your design and product !
Reviewer: ELOISE | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 06, 2019
Product: Sloth Pillow Case (Personalized)
The pillow case came very quickly and perfect!!
Reviewer: Corriveau | Verified Customer
Date: Jun 24, 2019
Product: Eiffel Tower Pillow Case (Personalized)
Love this & it was so easy. An agent with YoucustomizeIT, Traci helped me design it. She did it thru the chat. Great service all the way around
Reviewer: Cherry G Stephens | Verified Customer
Date: Jun 12, 2019
Product: Cheerleader Pillow Case (Personalized)
This is the fourth pillowcase I have ordered, love them! It's a great gift idea for kids! Kids are happy, parents that don't want more toys are happy. Great quality!
Reviewer: Staci Hegeman | Verified Customer
Date: Mar 19, 2019
Product: Custom Princess Pillow Case (Personalized)
Love it is soft and vivid images come out beautifully. Honestly the best image printing custom company I've ever purchased from!
Reviewer: Morgan Richter | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 20, 2018
Product: Design Your Own Pillow Case
Awesome! Fast shipping and can't believe how nice it turned out!
Reviewer: Teresa Honkomp | Verified Customer
Date: Nov 08, 2018
Product: Hockey Pillow Case (Personalized)
I appreciate the work done on my Pillow Case. The fabric is soft, stretchable, and strong. I know that my son will love his gift. He enjoys celebrating The Day of the Dead with the family, so I naturally figured that this gift is perfect for him.
Reviewer: Gerardo Alva Chavez | Verified Customer
Date: Oct 04, 2018
Product: Halloween Night Pillow Case (Personalized)
It was a homerun for 16 yr old grandson. Redoing his bedroom and the personalized pillow was the eye catcher of of entire room. Nice soft fabric and great that is fits over standard size pillow.
Reviewer: Karen keener | Verified Customer
Date: May 27, 2018
Product: Baseball Jersey Pillow Case (Personalized)
Overall the pillow case looks great and just what I wanted. But the zebra screen print goes thru to the back side and leaves a yellowish cast. I did not expect that. I actually expected it to have zebra print on both sides but that isn't the end of the world. There are also some black smudges on the edges of the case and a couple near the monogram. Hope washing it helps. For the price, I did not expect flaws.
Reviewer: Jayne Hartman | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 16, 2018
Product: Zebra Print Pillow Case (Personalized)
All our items are hand made, and a certain small amount of defects are "normal". That being said, if you would like to find out if the defects in your products are "normal", we encourage you to contact us via email with pictures so we can determine if you qualify to have your item remade at no cost.
Cutest thing in the whole wide world! Fits a standard size pillow perfectly. We actually bought it for our 3 year old puppy-child because she loved our pillows so much So her's has a big red "E" and says "Ellie". When we gave it to her, you would have thought it was Christmas morning. She now sleeps at the foot of our bed (80 pounds of puppy!) on her own pillow! Any child would love it too. They have so many designs, but her favorite toy was "Mr. Duck"....until we got Dino the dinosauer in the mail the other day!l Wonderful vibrant colors and great fabric quality. Perfect stocking stuffer for any child (or puppy)!
Reviewer: suzanne
Date: Oct 22, 2017
Product: Rubber Duckies & Flowers Pillow Case (Personalized)
Beautiful and fast delivery
Reviewer: Mandy B
Date: Dec 07, 2016
Product: Suzani Floral Pillow Case (Personalized)
Great quality and very soft! It was great to be able to personalize it and was a big hit with my niece! I would definitely buy it again and recommend it to others. It also arrived earlier than expected - a bonus!
Reviewer: Harvest Crush
Date: Aug 07, 2017
Product: Dalmation Pillow Case (Personalized)
Very happy with my purchase. Our granddaughters love them. They arrived quickly and the pillow cases fit our toddler pillows perfectly.
Reviewer: Patricia Fountain
Date: Sep 21, 2017
Product: Mermaids Pillow Case (Personalized)
So cute!
Reviewer: Steph
Date: Jul 11, 2017
Product: Vintage Transportation Pillow Case - Toddler (Personalized)
Super super soft. Gave it to by boyfriend as a gag gift, and he loves it.... and so do all the guys at the firehouse
Reviewer: smcorc21
Date: Sep 22, 2017
Product: Firefighter Character Pillow Case - Standard w/ Name or Text
Absolutely adorable. Love it
Reviewer: Mommy-to-be
Date: Apr 19, 2017
Product: Safari Pillow Case - Toddler (Personalized)
Load More Reviews