Reviews for Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round
What Customers Are Saying AI Generated Summary
- Beautiful Engraving: Customers say the engraved pie plates look beautiful and arrive well protected.
- Meaningful Gift: Shoppers give them for weddings, work anniversaries, and family recipe keepsakes.
- Manufacturer Seal: One reviewer noted the manufacturer's seal in the center makes the etching less clear than the preview.
See Product
Customer Reviews (Newest Reviews First)
Our engraved plate came out beautiful!! It came timely and was shipped well protected. We will be shopping here again!! Thank you!!
Reviewer: Jim | Verified Customer
Date: Jun 24, 2026
Product: Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Upload Your Own)
Beautiful pie plate. Engraved as requested. Quick shipping & arrival time.
Reviewer: Donna Gallagher | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 11, 2025
Product: Multiline Text Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
The embossing was excellent and just what I wanted. Unfortunately, the depiction showed a clear plate, but the glass seal in the middle of the plate from the manufacturer made the etching less clear. I wish that had showed on the previews
Reviewer: Maria Manning | Verified Customer
Date: Jul 19, 2025
Product: Block Name Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
Again, another work anniversary gift. Absolutely loved it!
Reviewer: Cyndi Reeves | Verified Customer
Date: Nov 26, 2024
Product: Design Your Own Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round
Arrived quick, beautifully done
Reviewer: Linda Simpson | Verified Customer
Date: Oct 01, 2024
Product: Interlocking Monogram Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
This is our second time ordering and we are consistently pleased.
Reviewer: Sarah Dover Savoy | Verified Customer
Date: Sep 25, 2024
Product: Design Your Own Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round
Very please with the ease of designing the gift and the fast service. Our niece was thrilled!
Reviewer: Teri Smith | Verified Customer
Date: Aug 08, 2024
Product: All Anchors Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
I really like both pie pans that I ordered!! The turn around time was extremely quick!!
I just didn't feel the design your own was user friendly!!
I wanted to be able to add a name and image. Or change the wording on a design....
I had to ask for help!! Ugh!! Not what I would call"design your own"
Reviewer: Teri | Verified Customer
Date: May 10, 2024
Product: Design Your Own Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round
Hello Teri, we appreciate your feedback and we are working to make our online design studio easier to work with.
The pie plates are absolutely amazing. Just what I ordered.
Reviewer: Candace Hartzell | Verified Customer
Date: Feb 08, 2024
Product: Multiline Text Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
Bought this for my sister-in-law for Christmas! She loved it and can't wait to bake a pie soon! (She is amazing at making pies!)
Reviewer: Debra S Bjorling | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 31, 2023
Product: Design Your Own Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round
A great birthday gift and having it personalized is a bonus! The birthday girl loved it!!!
The design/print was just as promised and the turn around time from ordering to delivery was incredibly fast.
Id definitely recommend YouCustomizeIt and order from them again!
Reviewer: Lori | Verified Customer
Date: Apr 28, 2023
Product: Name & Initial Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
Awesome product. Functional with a personal touch. Greatly appreciated by recipient.
Reviewer: Julia Blevins Richards | Verified Customer
Date: Dec 26, 2022
Product: Name & Initial Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)
I had a vision for my aunts and my mom's lemonade pie recipe.... and you guys made that decor vision a reality. Absolutely love these!
Reviewer: Chantay B. | Verified Customer
Date: Sep 10, 2022
Product: Design Your Own Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round
My niece is getting married and wants specialty pies instead of a wedding cake. This pie plate is perfect for the "Wedding Pie". Very nicely done.
Reviewer: Martha C McCain | Verified Customer
Date: May 13, 2022
Product: Happy Anniversary Glass Pie Dish - 9.5in Round (Personalized)